Welcome to Bagatelle
Situated in the vibrant heart of Key West, Bagatelle is a culinary gem blending exquisite dining with a warm atmosphere. Known for its artfully presented dishes, the menu showcases fresh seafood, like the astonishing Ahi Tuna Bowl and delectable swordfish, paired perfectly with a curated wine list. The chic, inviting decor complements the attentive service, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Guests rave about the stunning balcony views overlooking Duval Street, adding charm to every meal. With highlights such as their celebrated Key Lime Pie and personalized touches from the friendly staff, Bagatelle truly captures the essence of fine dining in a relaxed setting.
- 115 Duval St #6505, Key West, FL 33040, United States Hotline: +1 305-296-6609
Welcome to Bagatelle, a gem nestled in the vibrant heart of Key West at 115 Duval St #6505. This delightful restaurant embodies the charm and allure of its surroundings, offering an unforgettable dining experience marked by impeccable service, a diverse menu, and a warm ambiance. Imagine enjoying a meal on their inviting balcony, where the energy of Duval Street mingles effortlessly with your culinary pursuits.
One of the standout features of Bagatelle is its remarkable service. Reviewers rave about the attentiveness of the staff, highlighting how they go out of their way to ensure your experience is flawless. Whether it's crafting a custom cocktail or offering personal recommendations, the genuine hospitality here creates a welcoming environment that draws you in.
The menu at Bagatelle is a celebration of flavors, showcasing exquisite dishes like the Ahi Tuna Bowl, known for its freshness and aesthetic presentation. Diners have lauded the swordfish as among the best they've ever tasted, complemented perfectly by delightful sides. Their signature Key Lime Pie not only deserves its fame but also shows that indulgence is a requisite here—its fluffy meringue and satisfying tartness will leave a lasting impression.
Vegetarians and seafood enthusiasts will find their cravings answered with a variety of carefully crafted offerings. The seafood trio omelette and custom preparations for your catch are just a few examples of how Bagatelle tailors the dining experience to individual tastes. Those seeking an equally delightful liquid accompaniment will appreciate the well-curated wine list, expanding the sensory experience further.
A visit to Bagatelle promises more than just a meal; it’s a moment to celebrate life’s special occasions, whether a milestone birthday or an anniversary. With picturesque views, exceptional food, and an ambiance that exudes charm, Bagatelle has earned its place as a true highlight of dining in Key West. It's clear from the heartfelt reviews that this restaurant is not just a meal to savor, but a memory to cherish.
For reservations, dial +1 305-296-6609 and prepare to be captivated by the culinary wonders of Bagatelle.

My husband chose Bagatelle for his 30th birthday dinner, and wow—we were thoroughly impressed! We had a cozy corner balcony seat with an incredible view overlooking Duval Street, which made the experience even more special. Our server was fantastic—knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely friendly. I had the Ahi Tuna Bowl, and it was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. We enjoyed several cocktails throughout the evening, and even though sangria wasn’t on the menu, our server had the bartender craft one just for me (and a few others!)—and it was absolutely delicious. Bagatelle was high on our list to try, and it exceeded our expectations. So glad we made it part of our trip!

We had a WONDERFUL lunch experience at Bagatelle today 5 June 2025. Great ambiance, great food, and great service from Angel. We have been to Bagatelle many times before, and (based on today’s lovely experience) will be back again many times in the future. We sat on the first floor balcony, and ordered seafood trio omelette (my wife), and the hash with poached eggs (me). We enjoy Decoy Savvy Blanc wine at home, and were delighted to enjoy it here too. Angel was attentive throughout, with polite conversation and suggestions. When he discovered it was the 16th anniversary of our engagement, he brought us a decorated slice of Key Lime Pie on the house. A most agreeable lunch. Thank you, Bagatelle!

A great dining experience. Located in a charming house right on Duval Street . Very tasteful interior decor. Good wine list and menu. We enjoyed the friendly service and the absolutely delicious food. High end with matching prices.

Love this place because they will always prepare your catch & cook. The chef is so great and does an awesome job. We called and told them that we had caught some Cero and they bring it. They charge by the per person and offer three side selection which were all awesome. Great atmosphere as we set upstairs in the outside rail. The Rooster’s were roosting in the trees right outside, which was cool to see with great views of the Duval St. The service was great and chef offered multiple ways to prepare our catch. Blackened was our favorite. He came back and checked on us as they delivered our great catch that day. Pictures say it all. Will be back.

Bagatelle nailed it. The filet was buttery, the truffle sauce rich, and the burrata salad crisp and fresh. Mac and cheese gets an 8.5...just needed a touch more cream. Key lime pie and decaf espresso were both 10/10. Lisa made the experience even better. Great food, great vibes.

My wife and I really enjoyed this restaurant. We ordered the warm Brie appetizer which was fantastic. My wife had the ahi tuna poke appetizer for her meal and I had the swordfish. Both dishes were absolutely delicious. Probably the best swordfish I’ve ever had. We had the key lime pie for dessert and it was great too. Staff was super friendly and it was fun to sit on the porch and watch people walking by while we ate.

Everything thing about this place is awesome. We have been there before and the food was excellent every time. Last night we had Zee as our waitress and she went above and beyond to take care of us. I had the tenderloin with a crab cake and my with had the tuna. Both were Amazing. I highly recommend this place.

We stopped at the bar for a quick key lime cocktail and a slice of their famous key lime pie — both were incredible! The pie lived up to the hype (that meringue topping!) and the cocktail was perfectly tart and refreshing. Great spot for indulgence in the heart of Key West.